Michael Butler

Owner

Michael moved to the San Marcos area with his wife and four children in 2001 and loves calling this community his home. Michael graduated from Texas A&M University, Class of ‘95. He has a great love of family, friends, and sports.

With a wealth of experience and a passion for serving our community, Michael is committed to continuing the agency's legacy of excellence and personalized service.

Lindsey Schwaiger

Agent

Lindsey Schwaiger moved to Kyle, Texas in 2021 with her four children and quickly fell in love with the vibrant central Texas community. Since joining San Marcos Insurance Agency in 2022, Lindsey has specialized in commercial lines, ensuring businesses have the right coverage to protect their operations. She is passionate about providing clients with peace of mind, knowing their assets are safeguarded. When she’s not busy assisting customers, you can find her exploring the local area, enjoying small coffee shops, and spending quality time with her family. For Lindsey, life is all about community, connection, and savoring the simple joys — like a good cup of coffee and a beautiful Texas sunset.

Curtis Painton

Commercial Insurance Agent

With over 40 years of experience in commercial insurance, Curtis Painton is a highly respected expert in his field. A graduate of the University of Arkansas at Little Rock, Curtis has built a reputation for his dedication to providing exceptional service and personalized solutions to his clients.

Known for his integrity and approachable demeanor, Curtis is a trusted advisor who goes above and beyond to meet the needs of his clients. He has a deep understanding of the complex issues facing businesses and is committed to helping them find the right insurance coverage to protect their assets and mitigate risk.

A proud resident of New Braunfels, Texas, Curtis is actively involved in his community and is committed to making a positive impact. He is a member of several professional organizations and has served on numerous boards and committees.